And any resistance against the sovereign is immoral. Hobbes presented his political philosophy in different forms for different audiences. According to locke, political obligation must stem from an individuals own consent, and so must be selfassumed, based on a specific action or performance by each individual himself. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation. The ontological foundation of political philosophy notes preface hobbes began the study of geometry at the age of forty. Differences between the political ideas of hobbes, locke.
The interior beginnings of voluntary motions, commonly called the passions, and the speeches by which they are expressed 21 chapter 7. I mean that term to include both the obligation of the subject towards the sovereign, of the citizen towards the state, and the obligations of individuals to each other as enforced by a political. But they have become increasingly hard to address in an intellectually serious fashion and modern thinkers have become increasingly reluctant even to try to. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation luciano.
For instance, van mill makes reference to the use of freedom which plays vital part in hobbes s account of political obligation, and has been used throughout the leviathan to explain liberties and impediments, which van mill argues is profoundly confused. See, for example, strauss, political philosophy of hobbes. The political philosophy of thomas hobbes adelaide research. Nov 22, 2016 meaning of political obligation it implies that as man is a political animals. Introduce students to the political thought of hobbes and locke through succinctly describing basic biographical information about each man and the major events that influenced their respective perspectives on government estimated time, five to eight minutes. The liberalor modernview of political obligation is classically expressed in john lockes second treatise of government. Those born into an ongoing society with effective sovereign seem to be obliged by the.
This reconstruction begins with the first principles of matter and motion and extends to a unique account of moral consent and political obligation. Political obligation thus refers to the moral duty of citizens to obey the laws of. Warrender provides new insight into the nature and relation of the various types of obligation described by hobbes. Pdf between hobbes and locke john humfrey, nonconformity. In the liberal tradition, liberty is a central value, and so the fact that some individuals should obey others must be explained. Those born into an ongoing society with effective sovereign seem to be obliged by the provision of safety. It explains meaning, features, theories of origin of state, conception of state from different ideological lenses, and major theories of. Greens lectures on the principles of political obligation, delivered at oxford university in 187980 dentreves, p. Develop a theory of human nature in accordance with the scientific revolution of galileo. Provides a full defence of a theory of political obligation on the basis of the principle of fairness or fair play.
But i think that the two categories have quite a different complexion from that. For hobbes, social contract theory established the authority of anyone who was able to wield and hold power. Rousseau believed the liberty of the individual as the ultimate goal of any society but he also thought that this goal could be best realized through the political obligation owed to the state by its citizens. Mcclure, christopher scott, war, madness, and death. Some restrict themselves to subjective theories of value and.
While commentators agree on the basic theme of hobbes s theory, that people become obligated to obey a sovereign through the covenants they make either to each other or to the sovereign, they disagree on what hobbes took to be the grounds. Contemporary critics such as van mill has contested hobbes s political project as a whole, that which is disintegrated. The idea of political obligation is philosophical, focusing on the morality of laws, rather than justice. The subject of this chapter is hobbes s theory of political obligation. Thomas hobbes sought a reconstruction of philosophy, ethics, and politics that would end, once and for all, the bitter disputes that led to the english civil war. The phrase political obligation is apparently no older than t. Even hobbes holds that a law, though it cannot be unjust.
Journal of the history of philosophy, volume 15, number 2, april 1977, pp. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation springerlink. The book responds to the most important objections and extends a theorybased. Hobbess concept of moral obligation thus intertwines with the concept of political obligation. In what follows i shall outline what hobbes means by political obligation and the role of morality in the state of nature. Rather than study a narrow topic, i have chosen to draw a big picture, a basis for further systematic thinking.
The discussion focuses exclusively on the exposition of the theory in leviathan. Rousseaus idea of political obligation is understood through his general will. Download pdf authorityandpoliticalobligation free online. Hobbes subtly suggests that one motive for not breaking our political obligation is a persons moral duty to keep their promises. The english philosopher thomas hobbes 15881679 is best known for his political thought, and deservedly so. Discussion of political obligation grew during the era of social contract theory, in which thomas hobbes and john locke were crucial in explaining the idea and its importance. I mean that term to include both the obligation of the subject towards the sovereign, of the citizen towards the state, and the obligations of individuals to each other as enforced by a political superior. Develop a moral theory of political obligation based on consent iii. While commentators agree on the basic theme of hobbes s theory, that people become obligated to obey a sovereign through the covenants they make either to each other or to the sovereign, they disagree on what.
Thus, since the existence of a state is not justified there is no question regarding a citizens obligation to the state. This thesis considers the status of consent within both contemporary theories of political obligation, and within the theories of thomas hobbes and john locke. At the same time, however, strauss would reject the view that hobbes was within the. The consequence or train of imaginations 8 chapter 4. The variety of views that count themselves contractarian is daunting. As important as the early christians strong requirement of obedience were limitations they recognized. As indicated above, the subject of political obligation receives serious. His vision of the world is strikingly original and still relevant to contemporary politics. By thomas hobbes of malmesbury london, printed for andrew crooke, at the green dragon in st.
He opines that people in obeying the state should achieve freedom and this they can do only if they. Pdf commonwealth by institution and political obligation in. Lectures on the principles of political obligation t. Analyzes and explains the debates on political obligation. Political theory from hobbes lecture notes lecture notes, lectures 1 14. The two words from which green formed the phrase are much older, of course, and he apparently thought that combining them required no elaborate. Hobbes was against civil disobedience for 2 reasons. I begin the study of hobbes and political philosophy at forty. The paradox of honor in hobbess leviathan, journal of politics 76, no. The central questions of political philosophy have not lessened in practical urgency or in theoretical difficulty in recent decades.
Humans have a political obligation to obey a sovereign power, and once they have. Thomas hobbes of malmsbury was an english philosopher who gained popularity for his immense contribution to political philosophy. Jul 04, 2018 3rd july regular class hobbes theory of political obligation by rajesh mishra sir for details about class call 9899156495. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation develops a new interpretation of. Traditionally, this has been viewed as a requirement of a certain kind, to obey the law because it is the law, as opposed to the content of particular laws. With its earliest systematic postulation in the political philosophy of thomas hobbes, this theory gained much currency in the modern era. For hobbes the social contract is a form of trade off. Thomas hobbes april 5, 1588december 4, 1679 and john locke august 29, 1632october 28, 1704, although in agreement in some of their assertions about human nature and the need for government, held radically different perspectives about the ability of people to govern themselves. Unlike the elements of law, which was composed in english for english parliamentariansand which was written with local political challenges to charles i in mindde cive. Edmundson 1999 and sanders and narveson 1996 collect important articlelength contributions to recent debates and, among the many articlelength overviews of the subject, green 2002 and klosko 2011 are.
It proposes that prominent anglican clergymen, by utilising. Pdf the justification of political obligation researchgate. Hobbes on the basis of political obligation johns hopkins university. The political philosophies of thomas hobbes and john locke. Pdf the crisis of governance in nigeria is no doubt a daunting challenge. According to the account developed in the book, the directives issued by the sovereign as introducing authoritative requirements, so that subjects are morally obligated to obey them. Political obligation political science oxford bibliographies. The subject of this chapter is hobbess theory of political obligation. The moral obligation to obey the law, or as it is generally called, political obligation, is a moral requirement to obey the laws of ones country. Locke on political obligation volume 45 issue 3 john kilcullen. State of nature, in political theory, the real or hypothetical condition of human beings before or without political association. Social contract theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy.
Indeed, many hold that this is exactly what hobbes was writing against. This obligation of hobbes is of two typesmoral and prudential. I will examine the relationship between morality and reason by analyzing natural rights and the laws of nature. Hobbess theory of rights 12nov07dp university of kent. On the other hand, hobbes also rejects the early democratic view, taken up by the parliamentarians, that power ought to be shared between parliament and the king. According to this view, then, political obligation is subsumed under religious obligation. Much has been written about lockes second treatise, but still, i believe, the books main line of argument has been left unclear. Thomas hobbes has recently been cast as one of the forefathers of political realism. Unlike the elements of law, which was composed in english for english parliamentariansand which was written with local political challenges to charles i in mindde cive was a. Hobbes s leviathan, this article argues that both political obligation and a natural duty to justice are unnecessary to ground the ability of political institutions to en gage in legitimate coercion. In conclusion, in the state of nature there is no right or wrong only individual rationality and the right of nature.
Pdf commonwealth by institution and political obligation. In contrast to hobbes, locke opposes absolute monarchy. The ideal purpose of the state has been variously conceived in political theory, leading to competing theories of state, one of which is the social contract theory. Political obligation stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. I have entitled the subject of the course political obligation. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation book. According to this view of political obligation, citizens are obliged to obey the law because of a contract between them and the state the social contract.
Political theory from hobbes lecture notes lecture notes. Thomas hobbes presented a fully modern theory of political obligation. What political obligations, if any, do men truly have. Hobbes states unequivocally that the vir tuous or just constitute only a small minority of men in general, since unjust is the. Consent and the basis of political obligation with reference made to. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation ebook.
Political obligation in its historical context by john dunn. Many socialcontract theorists, such as thomas hobbes and john locke, relied on this notion to examine the limits and justification of political authority or even, as in the case of jeanjacques rousseau, the. This underpins much of hobbess political philosophy, stating that humans have a political obligation or duty to prevent the creation of a state of nature. This article evaluates his place in the realist tradition by focusing on three key themes. Hobbes on legal authority and political obligation develops a new interpretation of hobbes s theory of political obligation. Hobbes also developed some of the basics of european liberal. Some concepts need more prominence the duty to preserve mankind, the right of war, and private judgment. Whereas, in the late medieval period, the default position favored obedience, hobbess starting point is individual. The definitions of consent and obligation offered at the beginning of the thesis seek to capture the paradigm meanings of both terms. Political obligation 1 introduction political obligation is a broad notion and covers many things. By political obligation, theorists generally mean a moral requirement to obey the law of ones state or ones country. Political obligation is of immense significance in rousseaus theory. As with other components of liberal political theory, the modern view of political obligation emerged in the church, and did so according to a distinctive dynamic. In either case, hobbes said, the subjects consent to obey those who have effective power over them, whether the subject has a choice in who.
Feb 23, 2019 analyzes and explains the debates on political obligation. Notes in political obligation social contract legitimacy. Raphael problems of political philosophy says the citizens are obliged to obey the laws both because they have promised to do so and because the alternative to a politically organized society is the state of nature. His main concern is the problem of social and political order. While commentators agree on the basic theme of hobbess theory, that people become obligated to obey a sovereign through the covenants they make either to each other or to the sovereign, they disagree on what hobbes took to be the grounds. Hobbess view of human nature, challenge to aristotelianism. Political obligation is distinct from legal obligation. Eventually, whatever the will of the sovereign is, becomes your will. Among the many books on political obligation, simmons 1979, klosko 2005, horton 2010, and knowles 2010 provide overviews of the subject and are especially useful as introductions. Political obligation, simmons maintains, carries an implicit connection to citizenship, which means that those who are engaged in the political obligation debate are only interested in those moral requirements including obligations and duties which bind an individual to one particular political community, set of institutions, etc. This article presents a new understanding of how the context of restoration debates around toleration, magisterial authority and political obligation impinged upon lockes mature thought.
Does hobbes understand political obligation as a moral. His famous book leviathan established social contract theory, the foundation of later western political philosophy. Some have said, for example, that the citizen has an obligation or duty to vote. Thomas hobbes begins by noting that all people are basically equal in strength and intelligence.
The received view of thomas hobbes s political theory defines the individual rights described by hobbes as being, without exception, liberty rights, that is, rights that are merely freedoms. Consent and the basis of political obligation with reference. No single person is so smart or powerful that they cannot be defeated our outwitted by someone else or maybe a few others. Rousseaus ways of arriving at collective decisions is inextricably linked with the moral forms of freedom of the people. For hobbes, the english civil war significantly shaped his worldview. It is only when we realize these laws are absolute that we can leave the state of nature. Some hark back to hobbes and his emphasis on a preoccupation with ones own advantage, others to kant and his emphasis on a respect for others as endsin2 themselves. Others have claimed that citizens may have a duty to serve their country and possibly even to fight in its defense. Pdf coercion, rational selfinterest, and obligation.
1055 868 666 444 728 1215 1091 805 1178 361 1532 1314 147 481 139 339 430 1419 676 1197 962 703 346 466 1138 1341 975 1316 340 932 835 1042